Big-screen adaptations of Stephen King’s novels have launched countless actors to new heights. From Jack Nicholson in The Shining to Kathy Bates in Misery and Bill Skarsgård in It, King’s stories often lead to unforgettable performances. However, one casting decision that never materialized could have changed the trajectory of another beloved star – John Candy. The legendary comedian was considered for the lead role in the 1996 horror-thriller Thinner. Yet, Candy’s choice to decline the offer may have been one of the smartest moves of his career.
The Unusual Casting Choice for Thinner
Thinner, directed by Tom Holland (known for Fright Night and Child’s Play), is based on King’s 1984 novel written under his pseudonym, Richard Bachman. The film follows Billy Halleck, an overweight attorney who accidentally kills an elderly Romani woman. After escaping legal consequences due to his connections, Halleck is cursed by the woman’s father. As a result, he begins to lose weight uncontrollably, no matter how much he eats.
During a commentary track for the Collector’s Edition Blu-ray of Thinner, producer Mitchell Galin revealed that Stephen King initially envisioned John Candy for the lead role. According to Galin, King joked, “We’ll pay him [Candy] a nice chunk of money, and we’ll save his life.” But this wasn’t just a throwaway remark. King and the production team genuinely pursued Candy for the part. However, Candy ultimately passed on the opportunity.
Why John Candy Said No to Thinner
Mitchell Galin elaborated, saying, “He [Candy] didn’t spark to the material or didn’t want to do it. Whatever the reason, you respect it.” Despite the filmmakers’ enthusiasm, Candy’s lack of interest led them to search for other actors, ultimately landing Robert John Burke, known for RoboCop 3.
Candy’s decision to pass on Thinner was likely influenced by several factors, including his health and the nature of the role. By the time Thinner was in pre-production, Candy was known for iconic comedic roles in Planes, Trains and Automobiles, Uncle Buck, and Home Alone. Casting him in a horror film centered around dramatic physical transformation might have been a stark departure from his usual work.
Health and Typecasting Concerns
One underlying reason for Candy’s decision may have been the physical demands of the role. To convincingly portray Billy Halleck, the actor would have needed to lose a significant amount of weight during production, mirroring the character’s descent into skeletal thinness. Even Robert John Burke, who used a fat suit during the early scenes, lost approximately 20 pounds during filming. For Candy, who tragically passed away in 1994, this level of physical strain might have posed serious health risks.
Beyond health, Thinner risked reducing Candy’s talent to a spectacle centered around his weight. Candy’s appeal extended far beyond his physical appearance. Known for his warmth, humor, and impeccable comedic timing, Candy consistently demonstrated that his value as an actor went deeper than surface-level typecasting.
In Hollywood, many actors have faced pressure to transform their bodies for roles. Tom Hanks’ dramatic weight changes in films like Cast Away and Philadelphia have been linked to health issues, including Type 2 Diabetes. A role like Billy Halleck could have subjected Candy to similar dangers.
Would Thinner Have Hurt Candy’s Legacy?
Thinner is often cited as one of the weaker Stephen King adaptations, lacking the acclaim of The Shawshank Redemption or Misery. The film’s campy tone and lukewarm reception might have negatively impacted Candy’s reputation had he accepted the part.
Instead, Candy’s legacy remains untarnished, remembered for heartfelt performances that brought laughter and joy to millions. His decision to decline Thinner allowed him to focus on projects that aligned with his strengths, leaving audiences with fond memories of his unparalleled comedic genius.
Final Thoughts
John Candy’s instincts proved right in rejecting the role in Thinner. While the film found a home with horror enthusiasts, Candy’s health, career trajectory, and unique talent were better preserved by staying true to the roles that defined him. In hindsight, stepping away from Thinner ensured that Candy’s enduring legacy remains one of humor, heart, and unforgettable performances.
For those interested, Thinner is available for streaming on Paramount+ in the U.S.
Also Read:
- Nissan-Honda Merger Could Spark Massive Cost-Cutting, Warns Carlos Ghosn
- Sunita Williams’ Heartwarming Christmas Message from Space
My Name is M Anas. I am a passionate blogger with a knack for sharing insights on technology, autos, Mobile Phone, etc. With a creative flair and a commitment to delivering engaging content, Anas aims to inspire and inform readers with unique perspectives and well-researched articles.
